Most business partnerships start with trust and a shared goal. When a partner fails to honor an agreement, diverts business funds or makes decisions without required approval, it can threaten everything you have built. A business partner dispute is serious, but how you respond in the first few weeks can shape the outcome. Here is what California business owners should know.
What May Count as a Business Partner Breach?
A breach of contract happens when a partner fails to perform an obligation required by a partnership agreement, operating agreement, shareholder agreement or other enforceable contract. Depending on the agreement’s terms, examples may include:
- Failing to contribute promised money, property or work
- Taking business opportunities or clients in violation of the agreement
- Using company funds for unauthorized personal expenses
- Making major decisions without the approval the agreement requires
- Violating contractual restrictions on competition or disclosure of confidential information
- Refusing access to company books and records that the agreement requires
Whether any particular conduct breaches a contract depends on the agreement and the circumstances. Some conduct may also violate duties imposed by law, even if the agreement does not expressly prohibit it.
California general partners owe duties of loyalty and care to the partnership and to each other under Corporations Code section 16404. These duties address matters such as misuse of partnership opportunities, adverse dealings and competition with the partnership. The statutory duty of care is limited to refraining from grossly negligent or reckless conduct, intentional misconduct or knowing violations of law; it does not make every careless business decision a fiduciary breach.
For LLCs, the management structure matters. Members of a member-managed LLC generally owe statutory duties of loyalty and care. In a manager-managed LLC, those duties generally apply to managers, while a member does not owe fiduciary duties solely because of membership. Both members and managers remain subject to the applicable obligation of good faith and fair dealing. The statutory duty of care has the same limited standard described above. These rules appear in Corporations Code section 17704.09.
Depending on the facts, a breach-of-fiduciary-duty claim may exist alongside a contract claim or independently of a written agreement.
Steps to Take When You Suspect a Business Partner Breach
1. Review your agreements
Start with the partnership, operating or shareholder agreement and any related contracts. Look for the specific obligations at issue, required notice and cure periods, buyout or withdrawal provisions, and dispute-resolution clauses. Your agreement may require mediation before litigation or require disputes to be decided in arbitration rather than court. An attorney fees clause can also affect the cost and strategy of a dispute.
2. Preserve the evidence
Save relevant emails, text messages, bank statements, financial reports, invoices and meeting notes. Write down a timeline of key events while they are fresh. Preserve relevant records even if they seem unhelpful to your position. Deleting or destroying evidence can seriously hurt your case.
3. Avoid self-help
It can be tempting to lock a partner out of accounts, move money or change passwords. These moves can backfire and may expose you to claims of your own. Talk to counsel before taking unilateral control of company assets or restricting another owner’s access.
4. Watch the deadlines
Legal claims have time limits. In California, a lawsuit for breach of a written contract generally must be filed within four years under Code of Civil Procedure section 337. A lawsuit for breach of an oral contract generally must be filed within two years under section 339.
Exceptions may apply, and determining when a claim accrued or whether a deadline has been extended requires a case-specific assessment. Other claims, including fraud and breach of fiduciary duty, may have different deadlines. Seek advice promptly rather than assuming you have time to wait.
Your Options for Resolving the Dispute
Depending on the facts, the governing agreements and your goals, options may include:
- Negotiation: A demand letter from counsel can sometimes lead to a resolution or a negotiated buyout.
- Mediation: A neutral mediator helps the parties try to reach a voluntary settlement. Mediation does not itself impose a decision, and your agreement may require participation before other proceedings.
- Arbitration: An arbitrator decides the dispute instead of a court, subject to the applicable agreement and law. Your agreement may require arbitration.
- Litigation: Depending on the claims and applicable legal requirements, a lawsuit may seek money damages, an accounting of company finances, an injunction to stop ongoing harm or, in some cases, dissolution of the business.
- Buyout or separation: Sometimes the best outcome is a negotiated exit on fair terms so the business can continue.
Mediation and arbitration can offer privacy and scheduling advantages, but neither guarantees confidentiality, a faster outcome or lower costs. The right path depends on the agreement, the urgency of the situation, and whether your priority is preserving the relationship, protecting the company or recovering losses.
How We Can Help
At D’Oro Law Firm, APC, we represent business owners in partnership and shareholder disputes, from early strategy and negotiation through mediation, arbitration and trial. Learn more about our business litigation practice, or contact us to discuss your situation.
This article is for general informational purposes only. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.